Guest Reviews Archive
121 articles
Rocky Patel Fusion (Guest Review)
This review comes courtesy of our good friend Nathan.
You may remember Nate from the American Front Porch, Porchcast.
The Setting:
Morning on a Saturday. It’s a balmy 80 degrees on the Porch, with a slight breeze. All in all a good day to enjoy a cigar, and today I chose the Rocky Patel Fusion. Birds are chirping, trees are gently swaying, and a fresh rain has fallen. It’s a day that just says “chill.”
I must admit up front …
Dona Flor Selecao (Guest Review)
The Tom and Ed show is back once again for another cigar review. This time the guys take on the Dona Flor Selecao cigar.
MP3 Version: Right Click Save As
…
Rocky Patel Spring Collection 2009 (Guest Review)

Cigar: Rocky Patel Spring Collection 2009
Website: http://www.rockypatel.com
Vitola: 6×50 Toro
Filler: Nicaraguan
Binder: Pennsylvania Broadleaf
Wrapper: Sumatra
Price: $7-$10
Pre-light Appearance and such:
The newest line of Rocky Patel’s seasonal collections, is this review’s cigar. I first have to let you know that I received this stick from Justine, who manages the local shop that I frequent: The Blue Havana in Chicago. They received some samples from their rep and decided to pick up the line. It will be …
Punch Rare Corojo 2009
Tom and Ed are back once again with another video review. This time the guys take a look at the 2009 release of the Punch rare Corojo.
MP3 Version: Right Click Save As
…
Padilla Obsidian and Sam Adams Double Bock (Guest Review)

Padilla Obsidian and Sam Adams Double Bock (Imperial Series)
Today’s review will be on the Padilla Obsidian and Sam Adams Double Bock (Imperial Series).
Cigar Facts:
Vitola: Belicoso (6 x 54)
Price: Free (part of a bomb from BradInBuffalo)
Wrapper: Nicaraguan
Binder: Honduran
Filler: Nicaraguan and Honduran Blend
Beer Facts:
Brewer: Boston Beer Company
Alc/Vol: 9.5%
Type: Doppelbock
Availability: Year-round
Price: $10 a 4-pack
The Beer
The Sam Adams Double Bock is part of a relatively new series of beers …
La Flor Dominicana Salomon (Guest Review)

Cigar: La Flor Dominicana Salomon
Website: www.laflordominicana.com
Vitola: 7 x 64 Salomon
Filler: Dominican
Binder: Dominican
Wrapper: Sun-Grown Nicaraguan
Price: $25.00
Pre-light Appearance and such:
To start with, this is the La Flor Dominicana Salomon. This cigar was created and released by Litto Gomez of La Flor Dominicana in December of 2008. From what I read, they have had a second shipment this past month of March. They come in at a whopping 7 inches with 64 ring gauge at …
Reposado by AJ Fernandez (Guest Review)

Cigar: Reposado by AJ Fernandez
Size: Salomon (7.1 x 58)
Wrapper: Habano
Filler: Nicaragua
Drink: None
Pre-light:
Nice looking wrapper on a very large unbanded cigar. Cut the end with a borrowed pair of Xikar scissors a little over 1/4 of an inch up the cigar. Even with the small little nipple lit at the lighting end of the cigar the draw is perfect. The aroma from the smoke is nothing special to me. The opening flavor contains a pretty …
Viaje Platino

Cigar: Viaje Platino
Website: http://viajecigars.com
Vitola: Chiva 5×52
Filler: Cuban-seed Nicaraguan
Binder: Cuban-seed Nicaraguan
Wrapper: Cuban-seed Nicaraguan Corojo 99
Price: $7-$8
Pre-light Appearance and such:
I got this cigar from the girl who manages my local shop. I had read a little bit about them in a recent cigar press magazine, and it all sounded very nice, I was looking forward to trying them. This particular line is one of two blends and is the medium bodied of the two, …
Montecristo Open (Guest Review)

Disclaimer: This review was originally published at Cigar Tower after the Habanos Festival in Cuba. This review (text and pictures) is being republished on Stogie Review with the full approval of its creator, Peter Agardi. I want to thank Peter for bringing this to our attention and for filling in for my usual slot as I was away traveling this past weekend and didn’t have time to record two videos this week.
One of the most awaited announcements during this
…
Casa Royale Crown by Don Pepin Garcia (Guest Review)

This is the description of the cigar per Holt’s website:
“This cigar shares a wrapper leaf with Tatuaje’s prized Black Label. It certainly isn’t Pepin’s strongest blend but what it lacks in punch it more than makes up for with a complex and dizzying blast of flavors ranging from spicy earth and cedar to creamy leather and nuts. “
So it “shares a wrapper leaf with Tatuaje’s prized Black Label”, that tells me (even before receiving these) that …




























