Comments on: Camacho Liberty 2009 (Joint Review)

By: njstone

njstone — Fri, 19 Mar 2010 01:34:37 +0000

@ Rick — I bought a case of Liberty ‘09 as well and it DID smell like lacquer … pretty badly, actually, much worse than the Tat Drac boxes. I left the box open and the coffins out (they smelled too) for a number of days in my decently humidified house, and the smell dissipated quite a bit. The cigars inside the coffins didn’t smell bad, though.

By: Stogie Review takes on the Camacho Liberty 2009 | Camacho Cigars

Stogie Review takes on the Camacho Liberty 2009 | Camacho Cigars — Mon, 08 Mar 2010 21:36:29 +0000

[...] Via: StogieReview [...]

By: Chris (aka BeaverC32)

Chris (aka BeaverC32) — Sun, 07 Mar 2010 21:21:10 +0000

Nice review. The duration of the review was a nice change of pace. Watching this on a lazy Sunday afternoon while enjoying a cigar of my own was very relaxing. I like the average review to be 10-15 minutes, but again longer reviews are OK every once in a while.

I’ve never had a Camacho liberty but would probably pick a couple up in the future.

By: Craig (ArmyGLO)

Craig (ArmyGLO) — Sun, 07 Mar 2010 15:58:25 +0000

First off, great review as all are on stogie review. The length of the review doesn’t bother me. If it did all I would have to do is fast-forward. I really like the joint reviews. It allows two different, simultaneous opinions and experiences. It also lets you see the difference of cigars from the same box. The 2009 Liberty sounds fairly two-dimensional, cedar and woodsy.

Curious to see if anyone has let these rest outside of the coffin for a time before smoking, other than for the reason of having to dissapate lacquer.

KnightRid, I get a kick out of your reviews. Like me, you are not technical and just a regular guy with a regular guy’s opinion of his smokes.

Walt have you tried a splash of ginger ale in your bourbon? Nothing to overpower but just take the edge off. Of course I wouldn’t do this with a more expensive choice but I find it helps with those that are “middle of the road”

By: Matt Masters

Matt Masters — Sat, 06 Mar 2010 22:37:21 +0000

Besides passing out to this video last night and having to finish-up watching it today, I actually really like the longer video. I’ll just have to make sure to check the length, and not already be tired if you guys put out another video this long, lol. Most of the time I just have the video running in the background as I’m doing paperwork, surfing, or playing solitaire, so it really felt like a more immersed experience with a longer video like this.

But as far as the cigar goes, it seems like it’s worth a try. But realistically I could get two cigars that are really good for the price of this and not have to worry as much about the stick exploding on me like it did with Mike. But obviously if a special occasion happend to arise and this smoke was on my radar, then this would definitely be a cigar for me. Thanks guys!

By: Tom

Tom — Sat, 06 Mar 2010 16:45:59 +0000

Neat review/BS session. Was like chillin with you having a cigar. I have been tempted to try a couple of these but I’m gun shy with the price being so high.

As you mentioned about the scotch, yup I started off with Glenlivet 12 years and then Glenfiddich 17 year. I preferred the Glenfiddich, it just seems smoother and fruitier. I’m still nursing the Glenfiddich, while the Glenlivet was finished off awhile ago. The Scotch really cleanses the palate and with some cigars, it adds an interesting dynamic to the flavor profile. And just like Walt said, just a little is all you need. I have yet to get drunk sipping Scotch with a cigar.

By: JT

JT — Fri, 05 Mar 2010 21:42:32 +0000

not a fan of these at all. received a free box from a client and was very unimpressed. every Camacho I’ve had just fails to deliver